Configuration Matters - What Affects Server Power Consumption: Part 1 - Eye on Blades Blog: Trends in Infrastructure -
Configuration Matters - What Affects Server Power Consumption: Part 1

Following on from my first post I'll take a look at the affect hardware configuration will have on the power consumption of the enclosure.

To do this I went into the Blade Power Sizer and configured up two equivalent systems. I kept the enclosure configuration constant with just 2 x Virtual Connect 1/10 Ethernet Modules and 2 x Virtual Connect Fibre Modules just to simplify the example.

The Blade configuration was BL460cG1, 2 x 2.66GHz CPUs, 16GB RAM, 2x 1Gbit Ethernet, 2x 4Gbit Fibre Channel, 2x 72GB 10K SAS Drives.

Why did I pick BL460cG1, to be honest the actual server doesn't matter, what I'm trying to show here is that the hardware configuration can have a very significant effect on the enclosure power consumption.  The nice thing about the BL460cG1 for this purpose is that it shows this really clearly.

 

 

Configuration A

Configuration B

System

BL460cG1 x 16

BL460cG1 x 16

CPU

E5430 2.66GHz

L5430 2.66GHz

Memory

8 x 2GB FB-DIMMs

4 x 4GB LP FB-DIMMs

Base Ethernet

1GBit Dual-Port Multi-Function

1Gbit Dual-Port Multi-Function

Additional Ethernets

None

None

Fibre Channel

Qlogic 4Gbit

Qlogic 4Gbit

Drives

2 x 72GB 10K SAS

2 x 72GB 10K SAS

Enclosure

c7000

c7000

Ethernet Switches

Virtual Connect 1/10

Virtual Connect 1/10

Fibre Channel

Virtual Connect 4Gbit Fibre Channel

Virtual Connect 4Gbit Fibre Channel

Fans

10

10

Power Supply

HP 2250W x 6

HP 2400W HE x 4

Results

 

 

Idle Power

3698W

2900W

100% Load

5855W

4238W

 

The difference between the two configurations is 798W at idle and 1,617W at high load, which is a huge difference.

Where is most of the power difference coming from, well there are 3 differences in the configuration:

  1. CPU - E5450 (80W TDP) versus L5450 (50W TDP)
  2. Memory - 8 x 2GB FB-DIMMs versus 4 x 4GB Low Power FB-DIMMs
  3. Power Supply - HP 2250W versus HP 2400W High Efficiency

The power supply is worth about 200W (25%) at Idle and 300W (18%) at full load on this configuration. So it's a significant proportion of the difference at the idle load.  At the high loads, though, the majority of the difference between the two configurations is coming from the CPU and Memory.  A standard FB-DIMM takes approximately 10W per DIMM so the difference between 4 and 8 physical DIMMs is roughly 40W per server, additionally a Low Power DIMM uses 2W - 3W less than a standard DIMM.

So what can I take from this example? 

  • System configuration matters. A lot.
  • At high loads the server power consumption is the main factor
  • At low server loads the enclosure becomes a larger proportion of power consumption.

 What are the practical steps I can use to reduce power consumption.

  • Use the lowest power cost effective processor
  • Use smallest number of largest physical DIMMs that are practical and cost effective.
  • Use the highest efficiency power supply that is available

Comments as always are welcome. Let me know where you want me to go as I continue on with this series.

Part 2 of this series is Applications Matter

 


Posted 05-27-2009 4:06 PM by Tony Harvey

Add a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Remember Me?

Type the numbers and letters above:
Powered by Community Server (Non-Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems