China/New Zealand Contaminated Milk--It's not just about brand protection and anti-counterfeiting - Security Printing and Imaging -
China/New Zealand Contaminated Milk--It's not just about brand protection and anti-counterfeiting

This blog focuses on security printing to prevent product counterfeiting and provide brand protection. However, the principles covered, if applied in the appropriate manner and context, can protect from product tampering, from product diversion, from product smuggling and from returns fraud. They can also enable efficient, accurate recall in case of product compromise. And, as a consequence, these technologies can SAVE LIVES even while saving money, costs, and environmental impact.

Let's look at the recent China milk scare. It affects New Zealand...

See http://www.nzherald.co.nz/dairy-industry/news/headlines.cfm?c_id=168 for related articles on the New Zealand end. New Zealand exports milk to China to powderize and sell in China and/or export--such is the way of supply chains in 2008. And the reality of this situation is that unexpected problems with product tracking and recall have arisen [See comment below--this statement has been corrected per Helen's comment].

Of course, for the provider, the Sanlu Group, these are BIG problems: http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSPEK27908420080917:

"China fired four city officials and a company boss amid a widening scandal over adulterated milk powder blamed for the death of least two [three now confirmed] infants." Worse yet, the implication is that the milk was tampered with intentionally to hide the fact it was being "stretched": "Melamine, used to make plastic and other industrial products, is rich in nitrogen, an element often used to measure protein levels, and so can be used to disguise diluted milk."

How could security printing and imaging (alone or in combination with RFID, as appropriate) have prevented this tragedy? Repeat the mantra, "security is not about prevention, it's about detection and reaction". With uniquely identifiable, tamper & copy evident packaging/labeling, the offending products could be traced to the exact time and location for the assembly of these products. Sometimes inexpensively, sometimes more expensively, depending on the nature of the product and the nature of the risk to life and limb should the product be tempered with. It's more important, perhaps, to protect Tylenol than Ty-D-Bol, and to validate valium than to authenticate Old Spice. But no product should be able to slip under the radar--especially if you have to print something to convey product information anyway.

So, while several officials have now been sacked, tying the murderous manufacturing to the culpable culprits is important to help deter such a situation in the future. Security variable data printing provides auditing while helping in tracing backwards from the scene of the crime to the planning of the crime. It's about detection and reaction. It's about having every item self-report--in other words, a full provenance record on every product. It's about, possibly, saving a life.

-Steve


Posted 09-17-2008 3:18 AM by StevenSimske

Comments

Helen wrote re: China/New Zealand Contaminated Milk--It's not just about brand protection and anti-counterfeiting
on 09-18-2008 7:14 PM

Hi Steve

Just some clarification.  A New Zealand export company, Fonterra, is a minority shareholder one of the Chinese companies involved.  New Zealand is a major exporter of dairy products, not importer.  

StevenSimske wrote re: China/New Zealand Contaminated Milk--It's not just about brand protection and anti-counterfeiting
on 09-19-2008 3:55 AM

Thanks, Helen

You are spot on. The Fronterra products are being exported from China, but not to New Zealand. On www.nzherald.co.nz/.../article.cfm it states: "Only one company, in the southern province of Guangdong, exports its products - to Bangladesh, Yemen, and Myanmar." I was under the false impression that New Zealand, a huge dairy exporter, was exporting milk to China to be powderized there (which it is) and was then re-importing some of the powderized milk (which it isn't). My apologies for the error, and thanks for catching it.

Cheers, Steve

Anna Scott wrote re: China/New Zealand Contaminated Milk--It's not just about brand protection and anti-counterfeiting
on 09-22-2009 12:58 PM

Whenever, i saw your blog really i knewChina/New Zealand Contaminated Milk related new information.

Powered by Community Server (Non-Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems